Mutual Fund vs. Gold – Which Investment is Better?

By Tked August •  Updated: 10/13/24 •  6 min read

SA investment opportunities typically face the dilemma of choosing between the two, as both offer different benefits and monetary objectives. Mutual funds are a category of venture that provides immediate diversified exposure to various classes of assets, while gold is considered a hedge against economic turmoil. A choice would have to be made based on multiple things. These include understanding their work, the risks involved, and what returns could be expected from each.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Mutual Funds or Gold: Which is a Better Option?

Venturing in any of them depends on various elements. These include one’s monetary goals, risk tolerance, and prevailing market conditions. Mutual funds pool money from multiple investors into one fund. This cash is then invested into equities, bonds, or even both. Mutual funds diversify through professional management and give access to small investors for a broad market spectrum. They will work best for a long-term growth strategy and generally are suited for people who can tolerate some degree of market risk in return for the chance at higher returns.

Conventionally, gold is considered a safe-haven asset in times of economic and political meltdown, as it holds a historically significant role in South Africa and is regarded as a store of value among many investors. Unlike mutual funds, accruals of interest or dividends do not apply to gold, though it protects purchasing power during inflationary periods. Over its price volatility, gold tends to be more backward when equities are compared on a long-term return basis.

Is it Better to Invest in Gold or Stocks in South Africa?

With rich resources and relatively developed fiscal markets, the SA economy presents unparalleled venturing opportunities in gold and stocks. However, whether this lies in gold or stocks is a function of the prevailing market conditions and personal monetary goals.

Conventionally, gold has been seen as a hedge against the devaluation of cash and inflation. Since South Africa is among the world’s key suppliers, access to it in physical form or by investment instruments derived from gold can be much easier there. However, gold investing is suitable for preserving wealth, not aggressively growing it. It tends to do well during spells of economic uncertainty but performs poorly when economies are on their growth path.

On the other hand, stocks are shares in the ownership of a company and are usually highly volatile, while long-term returns may be more significant. The South African stock market can be entered through mutual funds and investment in individual share participation in high-returning industries such as finance, telecommunications, and mining. Dividend potential may also exist with stocks, something one will not get with gold.

Is Gold Fund a Mutual Fund?

Yes, a gold fund is one variety of mutual funds, but it works in a focused manner. While generally, a mutual fund would have a wide and varied mixture of stocks, bonds, and other varieties of asset classes, gold funds typically invest in the mining, refin ing, and production companies of gold. Sometimes, such funds may also hold actual physical gold or gold-related derivatives. This gives investors the leverage to take exposures in the price of gold without necessarily having to buy and store physical gold.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

It is one of the attractive alternatives to the direct investment of gold in South Africa through gold funds. Diversification in the sector would be achieved without complications in dealing with physical gold. Unlike a balanced mutual fund, they are far more focused and risky because their value depends on the performance of the gold-related firms and the price of gold itself.

Unlike mutual funds, while gold funds take on the nature of mutual funds, they have some heavy and strong concentrations on a single commodity. Hence, these are volatile. Investors are suggested to look at their risk tolerance before opting for these funds, adding to the outlook for the long run for gold.

What are the Cons of Investing in Gold?

Though certainly more often praised for hedging against inflations and economic downturns, disadvantages to gold exist, particularly for the long-term investor.

What Investment is Better Than Gold?

Indeed, several investments would yield superior returns for lesser risks than gold, should the time and prevailing market conditions be considered with personal financial goals.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Keep Reading

How to Start Real Estate Business in South Africa?

How to Start Real Estate Business in South Africa?

The discussion herein will explore profitability, the steps involved in creating, and critical considerations for starting a South African real estate business.

How to Invest in the RSA Retail Bonds – South Africa

How to Invest in the RSA Retail Bonds – South Africa

This article shall endeavour to provide an in-depth guide to venturing into RSA Retail Bonds, safety, tax implications

How to Buy Property Shares in South Africa

How to Buy Property Shares in South Africa

This article explores how one buys property shares, the benefits of doing so, and the possible risks of such an investment in South Africa.

Commodity investment in South Africa

Commodity investment in South Africa

It is paramount that both amateur and professional investors have deep knowledge of the local commodities market to realize opportunities and mitigate risks.

Where to Buy Stocks in South Africa?

Where to Buy Stocks in South Africa?

Major trading in South Africa's stock is handled through the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, but various other avenues exist for capitalists to participate in the market.

Is Now a Good Time to Purchase a Property in SA?

Is Now a Good Time to Purchase a Property in SA?

This article analyzes the SA property market and, in great detail, discusses what to consider when deciding.

Top 5 Investment Firms in South Africa

Top 5 Investment Firms in South Africa

This article reviews the top five investment companies in South Africa. It describes some key offerings that help them stand out in the increasingly competitive landscape of investments.

How to Buy Old Mutual Shares

How to Buy Old Mutual Shares

Buying or selling Old Mutual Shares in South Africa is relatively easy, whether you are a first-time investor or already an active one in the security markets.

Is It Better to Rent or Purchase a House in South Africa?

Is It Better to Rent or Purchase a House in South Africa?

Let's find out what is better: to rent or secure a homestead in SA, one of the significant features of the current landscape of property

How to Buy Offshore Shares in South Africa

How to Buy Offshore Shares in South Africa

The following tutorial goes in-depth on how to invest offshore, the steps, and legalities, with issues particular to South Africa.

How To Buy Dividend Stocks In South Africa

How To Buy Dividend Stocks In South Africa

Most firms listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange offer attractive dividends to capitalists.

How To Invest In REITs In South Africa

How To Invest In REITs In South Africa

In South Africa, REITs are listed publicly on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange; hence, this avenue gives investors an opportunity to realize income from both rental yields and capital uplifts.

Passive Funds: Are They The Right Choice?

Passive Funds: Are They The Right Choice?

But are they the right choice for South African investors? In a South African context, this article explains the benefits, differences, and advantages of passive funds.

What Are Multi-Asset Funds?

What Are Multi-Asset Funds?

They are the best for spreading risk and earning moderate to high returns depending on the risk profile of the specific fund.

How Much Do You Need To Start Investing?

How Much Do You Need To Start Investing?

This article looks into the minimum cash required, the options available, and how you can get started in SA.